comanche and apache indians – Apache Indians Genealogy

Overview
Overview

24-07-2016 · Comanche, definitely. But the Apache weren’t one group, the Comanche were a couple of autonomous groups that acted together more often than not. Granted, the Comanche were able to do so well because of repeated critical miscalculations by the

At the Council House fight in San Antonio in 1840 the Texans used a flag of truce to lure 33 Comanche chiefs into town to talk and make peace. They then made demands the Indians could not meet or agree to. One of the goals of the meeting was to get captive whites back from the Comanche. The Comanche brought one captive to the meeting.

Apache Indians The Apache Indians came from the Alaskan region, Canada, and portions of the American Southwest. Eventually the tribe migrated toward the United States further south, and divided itself into two basic regions, with the Rio Grande River serving as the dividing line.

The horse trade quickly became a large part of their culture, breeding, stealing, and trading horses to other plains Indians, allowing them also to become more productive buffalo hunters. Warfare was a major part of Comanche life with conflicts often bringing them

18-08-2013 · The truth Johnny Depp wants to hide about the real-life Tontos: How Comanche Indians butchered babies, roasted enemies alive and would ride 1,000 miles to wipe out one family. Comanche Indians were responsible for one of the most brutal slaughters in the history of the Wild West; However, Johnny Depp wants to play Tonto in a more sympathetic light

Forfatter: Jonathan Foreman

Comanche-folket er et oprindelig amerikansk folkeslag af sydlige prærieindianere, som engang styrede et enormt stort territorie kaldt for Comancheria, der spændte over adskillige sydlige amerikanske og mexicanske stater fra New Mexico, Colorado, Oklahoma, Kansas og Texas til Chichuahua-delstaten i

Religion: Oprindelige Amerikaneres Kirke, traditionel

The Comanche had previously been part of the Wyoming Shoshone. They moved south in successive stages, attacking and displacing other tribes, notably the Apache, whom they drove from the southern Plains. By the early 1800s the Comanche were very powerful, with a population estimated at from 7,000 to as many as 30,000 individuals.

Klik for at se i Bing2:43

03-12-2014 · The Comanche Indians Melissa Kimmel. Loading Unsubscribe from Melissa Kimmel? Cancel Unsubscribe. Working Subscribe Subscribed Unsubscribe 55. Loading The Comanche Nation arrive at Standing Rock –

Forfatter: Melissa Kimmel

Comanche Nation Entertainment would like to announce that Comanche Nation tribal members can cash their per cap and elder checks at any Comanche casino for free and they will receive a Comanche Credit.

08-03-2016 · The, Comanche, And Apache Plains Indians. 1267 Words Mar 8, 2016 6 Pages. The horse left a large impression on the lives of the Plains Indians; however, the real question being viewed is how this animal impacted the lives of, more specifically, the Sioux, Comanche, and Apache Plains Indians.

06-05-2015 · Before being moved to reservations set up by the early U.S. government, the Comanches were bison hunters known to use every part of the bison. Learn more about this Native American tribe in this exclusive video from Studies Weekly. Come learn more about science, history, and social studies topics with Studies Weekly at www

Forfatter: Studies Weekly

But in 1865 the Comanche and allied Kiowa tribes entered into a treaty that gave them western Oklahoma. The United States government reneged and war broke out again in 1867. At the end of the hostilities, the Indians of the Comanche, Kiowa, and Kiowa Apache tribes signed an agreement to settle on a reservation in Oklahoma, some of which was stolen.

Historically, the Comanche Indians lived in New Mexico, Colorado, Oklahoma, Kansas, and Texas. The name Comanche is believed to come from the Komantcia, the Spanish, which is their way of saying the Ute word Kohmahts, which means people. The Comanche Indians were seen as a separate group around 1700, having broken away from the Shoshone people.

Since the Comanche program was cancelled in 2004, I’d say the Apache. In theory? No contest: the Apache carries a 30mm cannon, while the Comanche carried a 20mm cannon. Both aircraft are designed to be resistant to 23mm cannon fire, so an Apache could shoot down a Comanche but a Comanche couldn’t shoot down an Apache.

30-04-2009 · Let me tell you about Apache and Comanche Torture – First off, hello friends!Second off, my dads family is Apache. One thing they teach white kids is that the poor Indians had their land stolen and they were just a bunch of sad Indians that got ripped off. Let me tell you

First hand accounts of capture and torture by the Comanche and Apache Indians Historical Records and Photographs of The Indians were already impatient for another victim,

The, Comanche, And Apache Plains Indians 1267 Words | 6 Pages. horse left a large impression on the lives of the Plains Indians; however, the real question being viewed is how this animal impacted the lives of, more specifically, the Sioux, Comanche, and Apache Plains Indians.

The Rise And Fall Of The Comanche ‘Empire’ Quanah Parker, considered the greatest Comanche chief, was the son of Cynthia Ann Parker, a white pioneer woman kidnapped by a

So the Apache quit farming and became nomadic hunter gatherers. The Apache kept spreading farther south until they occupied the Texas Hill Country. This is where the second wave of Spanish explorers found them in the 1700s. Around 1700 the Comanche came south along the same route the Apaches had followed years before.

Jul 27, 2012 – Explore nativeamericans’s board “Comanche”, followed by 15084 people on Pinterest. See more ideas about Native american indians, Native american history and Native american.

In addition to buffalo meat, the Comanche Indians ate small game like rabbits, fished in the lakes and rivers, and gathered nuts, berries, and wild potatoes. Here is a website with more information about American Indian food. What were Comanche weapons and tools like in the past? Comanche hunters used bows and arrows.

Indian Nations of Texas. Apache. The Apaches dominated almost all of West Texas and ranged over a wide area from Arkansas to Arizona. together with Comanche raiding, hit their society hard. In 1843, Texas promised in the Bird’s Fort Treaty to exercise better control over the

Kiowa, Comanche, Apache Ft. Sill Apache Indian vital records at Kiowa Agency, Oklahoma Territory, 1924-1937 United States. Bureau of Indian Affairs; Kiowa, Comanche, Apache, Fort Sill Apache, Wichita, Caddo and Delaware Indians: birth and death rolls, 1924-1932 Bowen, Jeff, 1950-Miscellaneous census records, 1904-1942 United States.

The said Apache tribe of Indians agree to confederate and become incorporated with the said Kiowa and Comanche Indians, and to accept as their permanent home the reservation described in the aforesaid treaty with said Kiowa and Comanche tribes, concluded as aforesaid at this place, and they pledge themselves to make no permanent settlement at

Comanche Indians would torture captured settlers by cutting off their genitals, stuffing them in their mouths, sewing their lips together, then staking them over a nest of red ants until dead. Comanche women often orchestrated the torture.

Kiowa, Comanche, Apache Lands Oklahoma Territory 22,233 Visitors before new counter installed, 4/2/2001 June 10, 2003 This is an Independent site dedicated to the history and genealogy of the Kiowa, Comanche and Apache Peoples that lived and still live in the southwestern part of

06-07-1956 · Directed by George Sherman. With Dana Andrews, Kent Smith, Nestor Paiva, Henry Brandon. Common efforts of the U.S. government and the Comanche nation to negotiate a peace treaty are sabotaged by renegade Indians and by the short-sighted Indian Commissioner.

5,6/10(450)

Indian Country Today Media Network asked Juanita Pahdopony, a noted artist and Dean of Academic Affairs Emeritus of Comanche Nation College, to share what she knew about the Comanche that other people may not know. “These are some of the things that I’ve loved about the Comanche,” she said.

Origins

modifier Les Comanches sont un peuple autochtone amérindien , aujourd’hui d’environ 14 050 personnes, dont la moitié vit en Oklahoma (ancien Territoire indien) ; le reste se répartit entre le Texas , la Californie et le Nouveau-Mexique . Drapeau de la Nation Comanche. Les Comanches sont aujourd’hui reconnus au niveau fédéral sous le nom de

Langues: comanche, dialecte shoshone

Even allowing for inevitable bias in such material, and even if only a small percentage of the horror stories were true–it would still show many Indian tribes to be sadistically brutal. There was apparently good reason settlers spoke of being captured by some Indians as a “fate worse than death.”

Mar 24, 2014- Explore johnsantuccio’s board “Comanche Indians”, followed by 152 people on Pinterest. See more ideas about Comanche indians, Native american history and Native american indians.

Apache (əpăch´ē), Native North Americans of the Southwest composed of six culturally related groups. They speak a language that has various dialects and belongs to the Athabascan branch of the Nadene linguistic stock (see Native American languages), and their ancestors entered the area about 1100.

(See Comanche-Mexico War) Although powered by violence, the Comanche empire was primarily an economic construction, rooted in an extensive commercial network that facilitated long-distance trade. Dealing with subordinate Indians, the Comanche spread their language and culture across the region.

Comanche Indians A large break off of from the Soshone with the arrival of the horse. They moved south and populated areas of the southwest. Tahnee mara does not mean anything in either Comanche or “Apache” (unspecified tribe) – the two native groups mentioned in the movie.

A Short Backstory of The Comanche

The Comanche, The horse riding native American warriors Vs. The Apache, The fierce Native American warriors Weapons Comache weapons Close Range Comanche War Club Medium Range Comanche War Lance Long Range Comanche Bow Special Comanche Scalping Knife Apache weapons Close Range Tomahawk Medium

While Dot was in training to be a warrior, the Comanche males did not physically abuse him as they had during his initial “breaking in” period. He got to accompany the Indians on two raids into Mexico, and on the last one they killed seven Mexicans and captured two girls and one boy. Dot quickly learned the fate of most female captives.

Forfatter: Historynet Staff

19-08-2012 · Sioux Nation, Comanche, Mohawk, Apache, Chickasaw, Crow, etc. I know the French, English, Spanish and American Colonials fought alongside with certain tribes, and had different allies, so it’s extremely difficult to single out one dominant, or most feared, Tribe Who was what Sparta was to ancient Greece in the Native American

The mission of the Comanche Nation Enrollment Department is to protect, honor, and adhere to the governance set forth by the Comanche Nation Constitution ragarding tribal membership.

The Real-Life Tontos: How Comanche Indians Butchered Babies, Roasted Enemies Alive and Would Ride 1,000 Miles to Wipe Out One Family. Jonathan Foreman, Daily Mail (London), August 18, 2013

11-12-2016 · The Apache and Comanche: The History and Legacy of the Southwest’s Most Famous Warrior Tribes – Kindle edition by Charles River Editors. Download it once and read it on your Kindle device, PC, phones or tablets. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading The Apache and Comanche: The History and Legacy of the

4/4(9)

The boundries were established in 1867 due to the provisions of the Medicine Lodge Treaty. This was taken from the Chickasaws and Choctaws in 1866 by the government so they could settle the Comanche and their allies here. The area consisted of 2,968,893 acres and was surveyed at 4,638 square miles.

Guide to Comanche Indians ancestry, family history and genealogy: birth records, marriage records, death records, census records, and other agency records

Comanche County’s first educational facilities provided schooling to American Indians. In 1871 Rev. Josiah Butler, a Quaker, founded Josiah Missionary School, which later became known as Fort Sill Indian School. Initially, the facility provided education to the Apache, Comanche, and Kiowa.

Comanche Indians. The Comanche Indians are a Native American ethnic group whose historic lands (the Comancheria) consisted of present-day eastern New Mexico, southern Colorado, northeastern Arizona, southern Kansas, all of Oklahoma, and most of northwest Texas.

The said Apache tribe of Indians agree to confederate and become incorporated with the said Kiowa and Comanche Indians, and to accept as their permanent home the reservation described in the aforesaid treaty with said Kiowa and Comanche tribes, concluded as aforesaid at this place, and they pledge themselves to make no permanent settlement at

Apache Tribe: History, Facts & Culture. Chapter 1 / Lesson 8 Transcript the Apache and Pueblo Indians had a peaceful and economic relationship with each other. When the Spanish came into their territory, some Apaches raided them and other Apaches wanted peace. However, when the Comanche tribe pushed into their territories,

FLAYED ALIVE BY INDIANS By S. C. Turnbo. In the month of September 1859 I read an account in the “Brother Jonathan” a weekly news and story paper published by B. H. Day, 48 Beekman Street, New York, of a white man being flayed alive by a band of Indians on the western plains in the early 50’s.

While the Apache survive today, they are secretive and least known as well as poorly understand. Although one of most discussed, dscribed, and written about, they have managed to retain their uniqueness despite practice of marrying outside the tribe.

Apache Indians Introduction The Southwest desert area including Arizona, Texas, New Mexico and even the northern tip of Mexico is considered home to the Apache Indians, also known as the Southwest American Indians. A small but very separate band of Plains Apache also resided in parts of Oklahoma and many still live there today.

Empire of the Summer Moon: Quanah Parker and the Rise and Fall of the Comanches, the Most Powerful Indian Tribe in American History [S. C. Gwynne] on Amazon.com. *FREE* shipping on qualifying offers. In the tradition of Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee, a stunningly vivid historical account of the forty-year battle between Comanche Indians

Anmeldelser: 2,8K

The Comanche, like the Lakota (Sioux), Cheyenne, and Apache are white-man’s Indians. They get cinema fame because they fought the European invaders and the government. They were, until the late 19th Century, imperialistic tribes that warred on smaller tribes and stole their land, horses, and game.

Comanche indians synonyms, Comanche indians pronunciation, Comanche indians translation, English dictionary definition of Comanche indians. n. pl. Comanche or Co·man·ches 1. Related to Comanche indians: Apache indians. Co·man·che

On August 6, 1901, the official opening of the former Kiowa-Comanche-Apache (Plains Apache) Reservation (KCA) as well as the Wichita-Caddo reserve produced Kiowa, Comanche, and Caddo counties, with county seats in Hobart, Lawton, and Anadarko.

Apache men tried to avoiding close female relatives of their wives, mostly their mother-in-laws. In some of the Apache tribes, men had to use polite indirect speech towards them, and also weren’t allowed to be in visual sight of the wife’s female relatives, so they had to evade them.

Die Comanche, auch Komantschen genannt, sind ein Volksstamm der Indianer Nordamerikas, deren Vorfahren zusammen mit den sprachlich und kulturell verwandten Östlichen Shoshone einst am Oberlauf des Platte River im Osten Wyomings lebten, bevor sie Anfang/Mitte des 17.

Synonyms for Comanche indians in Free Thesaurus. Antonyms for Comanche indians. 6 words related to Comanche: Shoshone, Shoshoni, Shoshonean, Shoshonean language, Shoshonian, Shoshonian language. What are synonyms for Comanche indians?

21-12-2019 · Some Apache Indians, however, are in favor of women being trained in weaponry and self defense, although this was typically a way of the past. A majority of Apache children will learn how to ride a horse at an early age and become expert equestrians. The Apache children also enjoy fishing and hunting with their fathers.

The Indians were caught by surprise and routed, with a loss of more than eighty men and most of their plunder. The Texans suffered one man killed and seven wounded. In October 1840, Colonel John H. Moore led a force into Comanche territory and attacked

Many Indians were recruited into both the Union and Confederate Armies west of the Mississippi, where they were generally used as scouts and hunters. However, the frontier army was mostly Union, and mostly made up of men who had no desire to face Confederate cannon. They instead were especially anxious to kill Comanche and Apache.

“There’s no rules to an Apache when it comes to fighting. The bottom line is if you’re my enemy, I’m going to kill you.” – Alan Tafoya, Jicarilla Apache/World Champion Knife Fighter “They would wait until the last possible moment to attack, until they were within a few feet of the enemy, and

Honey added flavor to the Comanche diet. The gathered food comprised more of the food they ate than the meat hunted by the men. They moved their villages often, following the buffalo migrations, which the men hunted in communal hunts. Apache Indians Eat

Apache – The Fiercest Warriors in the Southwest . Apache Before the Storm, An influx of Comanche into traditional Apache territory in the early 1700s forced the Lipan and other Apache to move south of their main food These displaced Apache then increased their raiding on the Pueblo Indians and non-Indian settlers for food and livestock.

Like the Apache women, Comanche women spent time on their appearance. The bands got together at annual powwows (gatherings, festivals.) The Comanche sang and danced at powwows to honor their beliefs. People often met their future husbands and wives at powwows. To learn more about the fabulous Comanche, read the very short story The Clever Coyote.

Tashǐn, Comanche name for all Apache. Tha`ká-hinĕ’na, Arapaho name, meaning “saw-fiddle man.” Yabipais Natagé, Garc6s Diary (1776). Kiowa Apache Connections. The Kiowa Apache belonged to the Athapascan linguistic family, their nearest relatives being the Jicarilla and Lipan (Hoijer). Kiowa Apache Indians Location.

 · PPT-fil · Webvisning

Map of Texas Indians Caddo Comanche Lipan Apache Karankawas Jumanos Click on the name of a tribe you would like to learn about first. Comanche The Comanche were from the Southern Plains. They lived in tee-pees They were hunter-gatherers. They got around by walking and riding horses.

Rare 1941 Signed Hc Tejana A Story Of Life With Comanche Indians Wilda Warren $300.00 Rare Rachael Plummer’s Narrative, Prisoner Comanche Indians, Texas Imprint Reese $250.00 Texas – Oklahoma Hist – The Old Sergeant’s Story, Gen. Sherman, Comanche Indians $95.00

15-09-2011 · Information about the Comanche Indians for students and teachers. Covers food, homes, arts and crafts, weapons, culture, and daily life of the Comanches. | The Comanche tribe

14-12-2019 · The Comanche Indians refer to themselves as Numinu, which can be translated to mean the people. The Comanche name is said to come from a Ute translation that means enemy or those who are against us. The Comanche Indians also had their own unique native language, which some of its members still speak today.

Lipan Apache:Morris Opal, anthropologist(1907-1996), who studied the history and culture of the southwest native Americans,estimated the population of the Lipan Apache was about 6,000 Indians in 1700. Those are a lot of Indians compared to the people living on my block. Comanche:The Comanche were the leaders in buffalo products,horses and captives.

 · PDF-fil

BLACK GOOSE’S MAP OF THE KIOWA­ COMANCHE .. APACHE RESERVATION IN OKLAHOMA TERRITORY . WILLIAM C. MEADOWS . Plains Indian cultures have left numerous forms of Native drawings in the form of painted and drawn clothing, robes, tipis and tipi liners, shields and shield covers, calendars, ledger books, religious and historical drawings, and maps.

The Government official, Commissioner Ward (Lowell Gilmore), has ordered the cavalry to subdue the Indians, by force if necessary. Black Cloud attacks a column of cavalry troopers and captures Ward. Quanah and a large force of loyal Comanche intervene and threaten to attack Black Cloud. Vengeful Black Cloud kills Ward.

02-09-2014 · Thank you, everyone, for the comments and thoughts. I have been thinking about the borderlands or buffer zone between the Lakota and the Comanche, the two most powerful geopolitical groups on the Great Plains.

Nel 1875 l’ultima banda libera di Comanche, capeggiata dal guerriero Quahadi Quanah Parker, si arrese e si trasferì nella riserva di Fort Sill in Oklahoma. Nel 1892 il governo negoziò il Jerome Agreement con i Comanche, i Kiowa e gli Apache, che ridusse ulteriormente le loro

Agreement with Comanche, Kiowa, and Apache Indians of Oklahoma. Sec. 6. Whereas David H. Jerome, Alfred M. Wilson, and Warren G. Sayre, duly appointed Commissioners on the part of the United States, did, on the six day of October, eighteen hundred and ninetv-two, conclude an agreement with the Comanche, Kiowa, and Apache tribes of Indians in

01-10-2011 · The Apache had few allies if any because the sense of ‘tribe’ did not apply to them as much since they where very family oriented in their bands before tribe allegiance and it was not uncommon to see Apache fight Apache and one of the reasons they never mounted a large raid on the scale of the Lakota or Cheyenne.

Se calcula que su población máxima fue de 20.000 Comanches. Hoy, la Nación Comanche consiste en aproximadamente 10.000 miembros; cerca de la mitad reside en Oklahoma (principalmente en Lawton), y el resto en Texas, California y Nuevo México.

The Apache, who were in the country invaded, attacked them but were defeated. In this movement the Penateka Comanche were in advance and from the name of this band comes Padouca, one of the old terms applied to the entire people. For a long time the Comanche were at war with the Spaniards and the Apache, and later with the Americans.

The Agreement with the Comanche, Kiowa and Apache signed with the Cherokee Commission October 6–21, 1892, further reduced their reservation to 480,000 acres (1,900 km 2) at a cost of $1.25 per acre ($308.88/km 2), with an allotment of 160 acres (0.65 km 2) per person per tribe to be held in trust.

Apache Indians. The Apache Indians are one of the most well known Indian tribes in the Americas, and they are also related to the other well known Native American tribe of the Navajos. Their primary location was in southwest America and mainly in the areas of Texas, Oklahoma, Arizona, New Mexico, there were also many in Northern Mexico.

The Camanche, and Kiowa, and Apache tribes of Indians, parties to this treaty, do hereby solemnly covenant and agree to refrain in future from warlike incursions into the Mexican provinces, and from all depredations upon the inhabitants thereof; and they do likewise bind themselves to restore all captives that may hereafter be taken by any of

The said Apache tribe of Indians agree to confederate and become incorporated with the said Kiowa and Comanche Indians, and to accept as their permanent home the reservation described in the aforesaid treaty with said Kiowa and Comanche tribes, concluded as aforesaid at this place, and they pledge themselves to make no permanent settlement at

Other groups were the Lipan Apache of south-western Texas and the Plains Apache of Oklahoma. The White Mountain Apache Tribe is located in the east central region of Arizona, 194 miles northeast of Phoenix. The Chiricahua Apaches were removed from their reservation in

Quanah Parker, chief of the Comanche Indians, has returned from Guthrie with the assurance from President Murray and other delegates to the constitutional convention that no provision of the constitution will prevent the sale and eating of mescal beans among the Indians of the new state.

28-11-2008 · Let me tell you about Apache and Comanche Torture. Page 7 – First off, hello friends!Second off, my dads family is Apache. One thing they teach white kids is that the poor Indians had their land stolen and they were just a bunch of sad Indians that got ripped off. Let m

The Comanche then embarked on a complicated 50-year pattern of alternately raiding the Spanish and trading with them, but their attitude toward the Plains Apache was unremittingly hostile. By the mid-1700s, the Comanche had shattered the Apache presence in eastern New Mexico.

The tribe’s present constitution and bylaws were approved by the Bureau of Indian Affairs in 1966, being represented as a tribe on the Kiowa-Comanche-Apache Intertribal Business Committee. Of a total of about nine thousand Comanche noted in the 1980 census, about thirty-six hundred lived in the trust area.

Description: The Comanche had previously been part of the Wyoming Shoshone.They moved south in successive stages, attacking and displacing other tribes, notably the Apache, whom they drove from the southern Plains.By the early 1800s the Comanche were very powerful, with a population estimated at from 7,000 to as many as 30,000 individuals.

First and foremost: they were mean suckers. Comanche warriors fought to the death and showed no mercy to whomever they defeated. Male captives were tortured, then murdered. If women were to be murdered, they were raped first. Even children were ki

They sold the stolen horses and women and children they had kidnapped. The relatives of the women and children would come to these fairs to buy them back. This kidnapping for ransom would later get the Comanche in big trouble with the American settlers who were much less tolera nt of it than the Spanish or Pueblo Indians were.

Get an answer for ‘What was the first European contact made with the Apache and Comanche Native American tribes? When? What were the relationships like between the Europeans and these tribes? How did they change over time?’ and find homework help for other Native Americans and the Colonists questions at eNotes

Facts about Lipan Apache elaborate the ideas about the Southern Athabaskan Native Americans. Before the 17th century, Lipan Apache occupied the traditional territory of New Mexico, Texas, Colorado, Tamaulipas, Coahuila and Nuevo Leon.

 · PDF-fil

1875—Quanah Parker led the last free band of Comanche Indians, who surrendered and were moved to Fort Sill. This marks the end of the Red River War 1892—Jerome Agreement—treaty negotiated between Comanche, Kiowa, and Apache Indians, reducing the reservation to roughly 600-700 square miles of

The Indian Census Rolls, 1885-1940 ( M595, 692 rolls) contains census rolls that were usually submitted each year by agents or superintendents in charge of Indian reservations, to the Commissioner of Indian Affairs, as required by an act of July 4, 1884 (23 Stat. 98).

Publication Details of Indian Census Rolls, 1885-1940, National Archives, Washington, D.C. Provided in association with National Archives and Records Administration. Census books enumerating Cherokee Indians living in communities and counties on the Cherokee or Qualla Reservations in western North Carolina are in this database.

Herman Lehmann became a popular figure at County Fairs and Rodeos. He wrote a popular book: Nine Years among the Indians, 1870-1879. In 1924, at an Old Trail Drivers reunion in San Antonio, Texas, Captain J. B. Gilbert and Herman Lehmann met for the first time since their encounter 50 years earlier.